Ali Alizadeh Reviews ‘The Best Australian Poems 2012’

17 December 2012


Best Australian Poems 2012 edited by John Tranter
Black Inc., 2012

Whatever one may expect from an anthology of contemporary poetry released by a mainstream commercial publisher – an accessible selection of diverse voices and styles, one for both the non-specialist, general reader as well as the (less snobbish) connoisseur, a selection featuring promising emerging writers as well as more prominent authors, and so on – Black Inc. Publishing’s annual Best Australian Poems Series has been meeting these expectations, more or less consistently, for close to a decade. And despite the series’ many specific strengths and few weaknesses, the latest addition to the series follows the same general tradition successfully.

In the interest of transparency – something that, in my opinion, our poetry communities could do with more of – I should declare at the outset of what will be a mostly positive review, that I was fortunate enough to have a piece of my own featured in this volume. This is not, however, the most positive aspect of this book for me. John Tranter’s selection includes not only some of my favourite poets – some of whom I’m pleased to call friends, a statement that I make also in the interest of transparency – but it also includes many wonderful poets whose works I have not read before.

I’d like to start by briefly exploring two of the stronger poems in the anthology. I’m thrilled to see Felicity Plunkett’s ‘Confetti by Dada’ (first published in Island) included here. If an anthology of contemporary writing is to exhibit the genuinely contemporary – as opposed to formulaic lyrical/experimental poems that mimic the established lyrical/experimental modes – then Tranter’s selection succeeds by including such perspicuous examples of an exciting, new poetics.

Plunkett’s poem is playful and experimental – as a celebration of Dadaist techniques and Tristan Tzara’s 1920 ‘Dada Manifesto on Feeble Love and Bitter Love’ – but it also creates a strong, confident authorial presence which breaks with the commonplace regimes of postmodern irony, witty self-reflexivity and the like:

Cut it out.
Open his love letters.
Take a pair of scissors.
Snip each word.
Place yourself gently
in a bag and shake:
your portrait emerges
rare, ordinary, interchangeable:
lips, adore, golden, dark, I.

The ‘I’ emerging at the end of this stanza is clearly not the egoistic, Romantic and much-maligned lyrical I – it is instead an undecidable agent produced by a process of ‘cutting’, ‘opening’ and ‘shaking’ – but it is, nevertheless, an ‘I’: the mark of a subject who speaks for the truth of the event of her being. Interestingly, Plunkett’s poem ends with a subtle rephrasing of the last line of Tzara’s original manifesto, with Tzara’s ‘I consider myself very likeable’ rewritten in Plunkett’s poem as (with my added emphasis): ‘I still consider myself / very likeable’. What this fascinating paraphrase suggests is that while the contemporary Australian poet is keen to pay an intertextual homage to the early 20s century Romanian avant-gardist, she is also stating that her fidelity to the event of Dadaism is conditioned by a historical distance – she is ‘still’ quoting Tzara – and that an affirmation of the poet’s contingent ‘self’, as highlighted by the inserted enjambment, is precisely what this distance necessitates.

Plunkett’s poem, in other words, is not a simple replication of aged innovation, but a genuinely new and properly subjective take on poetic modernism. A similar observation can be made of Jessica L. Wilkinson’s 10-line poem ‘Table Manners’, a terse, minimalist piece which, in the light of its first being published in The Age newspaper, may be seen, however credibly, as belonging to the same general aesthetic milieu as the work of The Age’s influential, minimalist poetry editor, Gig Ryan (who is also, to my delight, present in this anthology.)

Yet, Wilkinson’s is a radically dialectical, expansive minimalism. Her poem begins with an abrupt, full-stopped condensation of a universal referent into a particular metaphor: ‘Another day, another carcass to the dogs.’ But the poem soon becomes an operation of – put in Hegelian terms – a negation of the negation. The initial negation occurs with the vanishing of ‘another day’ into the ‘carcass’ metaphor, and then into realist, situational images in lines 3-5:

              – the sighs roll in the back door
with the spare change. One beer, two, sweat
down the bottle. Shuffle your feet
against the itch of the lino cut ...
This entry was posted in BOOK REVIEWS and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

About Ali Alizadeh

Ali Alizadeh is a Melbourne-based author and scholar. His literary interests include Marxist theory, Horror, Continental philosophy and history. Among his favourite authors are Shirley Jackson, Jean-Patrick Manchette, Richard Matheson, Alain Badiou, H.D., and Bertolt Brecht. His books include the collections of poetry Towards the End and Ashes in the Air, the novels The Last Days of Jeanne d’Arc and Transactions, and a work of aesthetic theory, Marx and Art. He is a Senior Lecturer at Monash University, Melbourne.

Further reading:

Related work: